Eczema, a common skin condition characterized by inflammation, redness, and intense itching, can be a challenging condition to manage. Many turn to skincare products to find relief and soothe their eczema-prone skin, from steroid creams to more organic alternatives.
Two well-known brands, Cetaphil and E45, offer products specifically designed for dry and sensitive skin, including those with eczema.
In this comparison, we’ll dive into the differences between Cetaphil and E45, explore their chemical ingredients, and consider the potential impacts on eczema-prone skin. We’ll also touch on the idea that organic creams may offer a kinder alternative for sensitive skin.
Cetaphil’s Approach to Eczema
Cetaphil has a reputation for producing gentle skincare products recommended by dermatologists. Their focus is on providing effective solutions for sensitive and dry skin without the use of overly harsh ingredients. Cetaphil’s Eczema Calming Body Moisturizer is one such product designed to alleviate the symptoms of eczema.
Key Ingredients in Cetaphil Products
While Cetaphil is formulated to be gentle, it’s worth noting that some products contain ingredients like cetearyl alcohol or cetyl alcohol, which could potentially irritate some people with sensitive skin.
Cetearyl alcohol is a mixture of cetyl and stearyl alcohols and is commonly found in many skincare products. While generally considered safe, some individuals with sensitive skin may find it mildly irritating, meaning it isn’t great for eczema sufferers.
Further reading: Cetaphil vs Cerave for eczema
E45’s Approach to Eczema
E45 products are spouted as ‘dermatologically tested’, which is actually very ambiguous and misrepresentative as being dermatologically tested simply means that scientists conducted tests on a very small number of variants and determined whether the people in the study had severe reactions or not.
They do not specifically test on those who suffer from sensitive skin, and as such this term is slightly misleading as it causes a general assumption that products are safe and suit all skin types, when actually the products are usually not tested based on how many times they’ve been applied; or if the skin will/can react under alternative, untested measures.
Key Ingredients in E45 Products
E45 products typically contain White soft Paraggin or Paraffinum Liquidum, also known as mineral oil.
Mineral oil forms a barrier on the skin’s surface, which can help to lock in moisture. While this can be beneficial for preventing water loss, in some individuals, it might create a barrier that traps sweat, bacteria, or other potential irritants close to the skin. This can exacerbate eczema symptoms in some cases.
Some people also have sensitivities or allergies to mineral oil, which can lead to skin irritation, redness, or itching, making it less suitable for eczema-prone skin.
Analyzing Chemical Ingredients
Both Cetaphil and E45 are supposedly formulated to minimize irritants, but individuals with sensitive skin may still find certain ingredients, like cetearyl alcohol or mineral oil, irritating, and it may exacerbate eczema symptoms rather than help them.
It’s crucial to read the ingredient lists carefully and perform a patch test, especially if you have a history of skin sensitivities or eczema.
Organic Alternatives
Consider that organic creams, rich in natural ingredients like shea butter, aloe vera, and chamomile, may provide a kinder approach to sensitive skin. These ingredients are often less likely to irritate and can be soothing for eczema-prone skin.
Because of the irritants in these manufacturers products, E45 and Cetaphil aren’t the best products you can use on dry skin, eczema, and sensitive skin. Instead, I recommend you try MooGoo’s products. They’re an Australian brand that specialize in organic products for sensitive skin, and have become such a favourite that they’ve since expanded across the world.
Their products have actually been proven to work on sensitive skin and eczema. They do not contain the harmful irritants, and they absolutely rescued my dry skin and eczema patches on my body (specifically on my wrists, in my elbows, under my knees etc).
I recommend the MSM Cream (my personal favourite), the Udder Cream (a favourite among everyone else!), and the Milk Body Wash. All of MooGoo’s products can also be used around the eyes for eye eczema, as well as elsewhere on the body.
1. What Sets MooGoo Apart?
MooGoo is dedicated to crafting skincare products using natural and skin-friendly ingredients. This commitment aligns with the preferences of individuals who wish to minimize their exposure to synthetic chemicals or who have experienced sensitivities to common skincare additives.
2. Natural Ingredients
MooGoo incorporates ingredients like aloe vera, chamomile, and milk protein, which are known for their soothing and hydrating properties. These natural components can be particularly appealing to individuals looking for skincare solutions that avoid synthetic or potentially irritating substances.
3. Gentle Cleansing with Natural Ingredients
MooGoo’s Milk Wash is a popular choice for those who want a gentle, natural cleanser. It uses a combination of five natural cleansers (instead of harsh sulfates) and milk protein for added hydration. This can be especially beneficial for individuals with sensitive or eczema-prone skin.
Further reading: E45 Cream vs Aveeno for Eczema
Finding Your Ideal Solution
In the choice between Cetaphil and E45, as well as organic alternatives, your skin’s unique needs should guide your decision. It’s vital to consider your individual sensitivities, allergies, and eczema severity.
Patch testing new products is a valuable practice, and consulting with a dermatologist can offer personalized recommendations. Some individuals even find that a combination of products from different brands works best for their skin – I personally use a mix of MooGoo and Balmonds.
Remember that while Cetaphil and E45 both ‘aim’ to minimize irritants, what works for one person may not work for another. In the pursuit of healthy, comfortable skin, your skin’s preferences should be the ultimate guide.
The Gentle Touch of Organic Creams
Organic creams have gained popularity for their minimal use of synthetic or potentially irritating ingredients. They often incorporate natural oils, botanical extracts, and soothing elements. Such products can be a favorable option for individuals with sensitive skin and eczema, offering a gentle and nurturing approach to skincare.
In summary, the journey to managing eczema and caring for sensitive skin involves exploring various options, including established brands like Cetaphil and E45. However, as more individuals seek natural and organic alternatives, the world of skincare continues to evolve.
Your skin’s unique needs and sensitivities should be the ultimate factor in determining the best products for your eczema-prone skin. By staying informed about ingredients and performing patch tests, you can find the ideal solution for your skin’s comfort and health.
